According
to Sigmund Freud, everything we do is motivated by underlying sexual desires.
No matter what our motives are on the surface, our libido subconsciously drives
it all. I don’t know how much value I normally see in psychoanalyzing fictional
characters, but I do think that Freud’s theory on sex drives can be applied to
fiction as well. In many fictional works, the plot and the characters are
driven by sex. Look at Cat’s Cradle, for
example. Sexual desire for Mona motivates Jonah to go to San Lorenzo. In The Things They Carried, sex (and love,
I suppose) is the reason Mark Fossie ships his girlfriend to Vietnam, the
reason Dobbins wears his girlfriend’s panties around his neck, and the reason
Jimmy Cross is constantly preoccupied. In Man
in the High Castle everything Frank Frink does is with hopes that he can
get Juliana back. I could go into more depth on each of these, but I’m going to
look at Kindred.
Rufus is
the prime example of sex drive as an underlying motivation. The most obvious
example is in his treatment of Alice. He only agrees to let her kids be
educated and freed because he doesn’t want to lose his sexual object. His
treatment of Dana, on the other hand seems motivated by something else –
perhaps gratitude or fear – for most of the novel. He fears abandonment by her
so he refuses to let her leave. We find out at the end, however, that sex was
behind this as well. His sale of Joe simply because he talks to Dana indicates
some desire and jealousy in Rufus. Then when Rufus says that Dana and Alice are
one woman, all of his lust for Alice is transferred to Dana. It’s no secret
that Rufus has strong sexual desire for Alice, and if he views Dana and Alice
as one then he must have the same desire for Dana. His attempted rape of Dana
at the end confirms this. So while on the surface he doesn’t want Dana to leave
because he fears being alone, his deeper motivation is driven by his libido.
I agree that some of what Rufus does is do to his sex drive, Alice for example, but I don't think you can transfer this same motivation to his treatment of Dana. At the end of the novel he does try and rape her, but it is because he fears abandonment. Sex is the ultimate connection someone can have with another person and Rufus believes that if he impregnates Dana she will be forced to stay. Rufus is just a scared kid who doesn't want to be left alone again.
ReplyDeleteIm not sure if I truly believe in Freud's theory of sexual desires being the drive of all man. In the case of Rufus it is clear that this is the case however. His selling and treatment of slaves completely reflects his sexual desires for both Alice and Edana. However, Im not sure if I can say that everything the other characters do is out of sexual desire. I believe that in many cases there are sincere altruistic qualities that exist within the characters portrayed, especially in The Things They Carried.
ReplyDelete