When I was thinking about manipulative forces in my life, I
at first thought of all the obvious ones, or the ones that most people are
already aware of. Advertising, peers, our school, magazines, books all came to
mind. But since the point of this course is to become aware of more forces, I
then tried to dig deeper, seek out manipulation where I had not seen it before.
If we think of manipulation as a form of influence, then really everyone in my
life manipulates me. What I thought about, and am still thinking about, was
whether I every am “guilty” of manipulating myself. At first this seemed dumb,
but the more I thought about it the more I realized that really most of the
beliefs, most of the times I’ve been judged have really been by myself. Usually
society plants the idea in your head, but it is in fact our own choice whether
to accept it. Most clothing brands
cater to the idea that you can become “more or less beautiful” based on what
you wear. But what I am suggesting
is that we could take them manipulation and turn it right back around. When you
wear a shirt you don’t really like, or don’t feel comfortable in, you seem less
confident. Maybe you look around more at how people are reacting to you, wary
of any strange glances. But suppose you took the ugliest outfit you could think
of and walked as if you looked the best you had even looked. It could be
contagious, you could start to manipulate other people right away. Kind of like
fake it till you make it. If you think you look great, you probably consciously
or unconsciously act in a way that inspires greatness. What if we turned right
back around to clothes designers and said, but yeah, it’s not what you wear but
how you wear it? There would be no comeback. Many times someone plants an idea
in your head: you have to write this essay; this book is the best book ever
written; you have to be more athletic to play hockey than to play baseball. But
then we obsess over it, taking them one comment and turning it from a
subjective idea to a force of manipulation. We manipulate
ourselves when we make every message society sends out ten times more dramatic.
So yes, the media will keep trying to enforce their values on us, but we can
take it or leave it.
I completely agree with your theory, and I thought of something else while reading your post. Usually the kids that are the most popular are the ones who act as if they don't care what anyone has to say. I've often heard people complain that they don't like being around them because they seem like they are "trying too hard" to see cool. Unfortunately, I see an inherent type of manipulation in this as well because the kids that are "trying too hard" are simply not as good as the other kids at faking it. We are told to be confident and not care what anyone thinks of us, but that is way harder than anyone ever says.
ReplyDelete