Manipulators of Destiny in "An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge" and "Supernatural"

            Since the beginning of human existence, we have pondered the question of whether or not we are really in control of our own destinies. From the beliefs of John Calvin to the lyrics of “Freewill” by Rush, these sentiments are often present. Even the most rational thinkers have at some point questioned whether or not they are really in control.

            Both “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” and “Supernatural” tackle this fundamental question of humanity in entirely different ways. While both stories involve the twisting and distortion of what is real and what is fake, Peyton Farquhar is confronted by someone entirely real at the start of “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge.” The Federal spy tricks Peyton into attempting to destroy the bridge, ultimately ensnaring him in a trap of Federal soldiers who immediately capture and (at least attempt to) hang him. In this respect, Peyton’s destiny is totally manipulated by this spy. Instead of living out a comfortable and satisfying life with his wife and children at his plantation, he is left to hang from a noose surrounded by his enemies.

            In “The Monster at the End of This Book,” Sam and Dean meet Chuck, who is able to predict in writing what will happen in their lives. When he predicts that Sam will engage in a “night of demonic passion” with Lilith, Dean is confronted with a major dilemma: Can he change the seemingly inevitable and horrific situation that Sam will face? In the end Dean and Chuck are able to save Sam from Lilith, indicating that although we may be predisposed to encounter some situations, we do have the power to change them.