The videos of Timothy Treadwell were fascinating. Not only does Timothy seem to
disassociate himself with the rest of humanity by thinking that it is his duty
to protect bears from other people, but he thinks he has enough know-how to
teach the bear how to survive. For
example, in one of the later videos, Timothy talks about how Downey is
struggling to catch fish. He
proceeds to tell her, rather condescendingly, how to catch the fish. He yells to her across the pond, “you have
to actually work for it, you have to actually produce an effort.” He anthropomorphizes Downey, even
though he is essentially trying to protect her from mankind. This is highly contradictory because he
doesn’t want man to dominate over the bears, but yet he treats Downey as if he
is superior and knows better than she does at surviving.
Though it is quite prevalent with the case of Timothy
Treadwell, people today often believe that they are inherently better than the
other beings in the world and feel an inherent right to dominate over other
creatures. It also stems into feeling
the right to dominate over other people.
This kind of mindset is not only troubling, but is part of the reason we
have such an unequal society. We
can learn a lot from Timothy Treadwell.
We shouldn’t assume that we know better than the person or creature
beside us because we don’t. We
need to be less condescending, more understanding, and realize that though we
may be at the top of the food chain, we need each member of it to keep us
alive.
I think that the idea of dominance over other creatures is very interesting. After discussing the perception so much in class, I think it's more understandable as to why some have this feeling of superiority and others strive to treat animals equally. Having said this, it makes it so much more difficult to justify each approach.
ReplyDelete