I hate the word manipulation. We
have overused this word so much in our past few classes that I swear it’s
almost as bad as people saying “like” all of the time. I get it; books
manipulate us, advertising manipulates us, social norms manipulate us, grade
inflation manipulates us, but our endless droning on about manipulation is beginning
to manipulate me to not care anymore. Why is that? Manipulation is obviously an
ever present and frequently harmful thing in my life. Why have I gotten to the
point that I just don’t care? Because I know too much, and if I kept in mind
every way in which I was being manipulated by every product and every
stimulation at every moment in my life, I would undoubtedly go insane. In this
course, we have examined the practical implications of the concept of
manipulation to the point that we can just almost now see how it is all
connected: how none of our decisions are really our own. How all people are
simply in a “choose your own adventure” novel where they aren’t allowed even
the control of realizing when they make the choice to change their stories. I
feel that our class discussions have brought me all too close to realizing the
implications of this concept. I feel like Mr. Tagomi from The Man in the
High Castle: finally, when I begin to understand what I’ve been working and
reading and striving and studying to understand, I realize that I’d prefer not
to understand it after all. To recognize this, I had to be close enough to see
this issue but far enough away that I’ve not yet been consumed by it. So I’ll
not step any closer. I’m through overthinking my decisions and those of others.
What I mean is: I get why the ‘foma’ is so appealing and I think I’ll give it a
spin.
I understand how you feel. It is unnerving to think about all of the manipulation (sorry to use the word) and how greatly it affects you. The world feels unstable. I always knew this, but have never had to think so deeply about exactly what that means—how not only do our decisions seem insignificant, but they are no longer our own. But you do not need to be aware of these manipulations all the time. In fact, even now you aren't. It's impossible. Knowing that they exist doesn't mean you don't have to care, it just means that you are able to think more critically about the decisions you make. Like choosing to live by a 'foma.' It is the caring that got you to that decision.
ReplyDeleteAmen to that, Abby. I think being manipulated can be really fun! I posted last week about how I love commercials, and I brought in one of my several infomercial products for the artifacts discussion…so yes, I absolutely agree that we don't need to care. I say embrace it.
ReplyDelete