I want to start my post with
apologizing for it being late. I could come up with some excuse, like I was
just so traumatized by the bomb threat or I’m not going to be manipulated into
doing something on time. But really I just forgot, sorry. Today all the
sophomores picked their classes for next semester. This is always an extremely
stressful process. Everyone wants to get into the same easy classes and ends up
scrambling when they don’t get in. My biggest issue with this is the show that
Hamilton puts on about it. On the tours you always hear about the open
curriculum and how this gives you so many different options. This is supposed
to be one of the great defining characteristics of Hamilton. So why does it
feel like I have no options every time I go to register? You need a
prerequisite for this class, this one has 20 spots but only 2 for juniors, and
this one is only offered for specific majors. It’s such an illusion of choice. You’re
supposed to be able to learn whatever you want in college, but really it’s
limited to those certain classes that the college has chosen. And there are so
many limitations that you really don’t have many choices at all. Another
illusion here is the fact that you have so much time to take a lot of different
classes. At my first advisor meeting I was told I had 32 classes to take while
here, and it sounded like so many. I remember being worried I would run out of
easy classes to take. When you factor in going abroad, your major, maybe a
minor, and maybe pre-med or pre-law requirements you don’t get to chose any of
your classes anymore. For my last semesters here at Hamilton I will be able to
pick 1 class, all the others have been decided for me by requirements. I chose to
do this, so this is fine, I’ve accepted it. However, it is completely unfair
that we market our school in a way that gives people such an illusion of choice
when there is very little choice at all.
K.C. I could not agree with you more. Your post is a more articulate version of mine. The only difference is that I feel like I have too many options. I only needed to take one class for my major next semester and I struggled to decide what else to take. I was wishing I had someone who would just tell me what to take. I'm sure if I was in your situation I would feel exactly how you do. It's interesting that when I have a lot of choice I want less and when I have little choice I want more. Seems like a "grass is always greener" situation. Either way, I also find the registration extremely stressful and misleading.
ReplyDeleteYou made some great points, and I definitely have had some of the same struggles. As an Econ/Chem double major, I too have very few "open" classes left. I think that the way you're looking at it is smart. It's a choice with parameters, but you're satisfied with your choice. In many ways, maybe a true liberal arts education wouldn't have any majors at all, but would truly allow for students to branch out in as many ways as they want.
ReplyDelete